A comprehensive and easily accessible directory of Employee Leasing Services nationwide
help small business Attract and Retain quality employees by offering quality benefits through Employee Leasing Services
Foster an environment of fellowship and free exchange of ideas among member Employee Leasing Companies

  to fill out a simple form to connect to Employee Leasing Services in your area.

Amazon.Com v. Magee

9/22/2005



In this appeal, we consider whether an employee who is treated for injuries sustained on the job is considered temporarily totally disabled or temporarily partially disabled when she is able to return to work on a part-time basis. We conclude that a worker released to work with restrictions is only temporarily partially disabled; therefore, her position and salary need not comport with NRS 616.475, which sets forth standards regarding when an employer, by offering modified employment, can cease making temporary total disability payments. Thus, a temporarily partially disabled employee must be compensated at the rate set forth in NRS 616C.500(1).


FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY


On April 18, 2001, respondent Dee Dee Magee injured her right wrist while working at her job with appellant Amazon.com in Fernley, Nevada. Magee sought treatment at a local emergency room, and after an examination, the treating physician diagnosed her injury as possible carpal tunnel syndrome, placed her in a forearm splint and prescribed naproxen. No x-rays were taken at that time.


On April 23, 2001, Magee sought further medical advice regarding the cause and extent of her injury. After an examination, Magee was advised that her symptoms did not coincide with obvious carpal tunnel syndrome but that she should continue to wear the forearm splint for two weeks. The physician noted that Magee should be placed on restricted duty, without elaborating on the nature of the restrictions.


From May 14 to June 10, 2001, Magee visited several physicians. At the conclusion of each visit, Magee was released to light-duty work subject to certain physical restrictions and limitations. After a June 11, 2001 visit, Magee was released to light-duty work with a four-hour-a-day work restriction.


On August 13, 2001, Magee underwent corrective surgery on her right wrist. Following the surgery, she experienced pain in her left hand and was subsequently diagnosed with carpal tunnel syndrome in her left wrist. Consequently, Magee underwent a second surgery to repair her left wrist. On October 30, 2001, Magee was released to full-duty work with no restrictions.


Before the initial wrist injury, Magee worked approximately ten hours per day, four days a week, for a total of forty hours per week. She was paid $10.00 per hour for a gross weekly wage of $400.00. After her initial wrist injury, when Magee was restricted in the number of hours she could work, she still earned $10.00 an hour. The record indicates that her daily and weekly hours varied, but that she generally never worked more than four hours a day or sixteen hours a week.


Magee eventually submitted workers' compensation claims for the injuries to her wrists. Amazon.com never disputed Magee's diagnosis or that her condition was the result of her employment. Ultimately, Amazon.com's insurer made separate determinations regarding Magee's claims.


For the period of May 5 through October 30, 2001, the insurer found that Magee was eligible for temporary partial disability benefits under NRS 616C.500, with at least two periods when she was eligible for temporary total disability benefits. The first period of Magee's temporary total disability, which began after the right-wrist surgery on August 13, 2001, was terminated on August 24, 2001, because she returned to light-duty work and collected temporary partial disability benefits. Temporary total disability benefits were reinstated on October 3, 2001, due to Magee's left-wrist surgery, but were terminated on October 16, 2001, after her physician released her to light-duty work. Finally, based upon her release to full-duty work with no restrictions on October

Page 1 2 3 

Nevada Employee Leasing Services    Employee Leasing Services


  to fill out a simple form to connect to Employee Leasing Services in your area.

Employee Leasing Who Is the Employer? Hiring/Firing Issues
Employee Leasing Advantage Employee Leasing Models Human Resources Management
Employee Handbooks American with Disabilities Act (ADA) Employers Practice Liability Insurance (EPL)
Employment Forms, Postings Sexual Harassment at workplace Employee Leasing vs. Temp
Administrative Services Organization (ASO) Human Resources Organization (HRO) Professional Employer Organization (PEO)
Payroll Services Human Resources Workers Compensation Codes
FDP  |   RSS Feeds  |  Articles  |  Jobs  |  Inquiries  |  Partner Websites
SiteMap  | Trading Partners  | Register  | Case LawsFAQ | Employee Leasing Forum | Employee Leasing Directory  | Success Stories
Terms of Service  Copyright © 2004. “Employee-Leasing.org ”. All rights reserved.